This subject has probably led to more campfire discussions - and arguments - than any other among hunters. I doubt it will ever be answered in such a way as to please everyone. I happen to have slain a goodly number of deer over the years, and feel pretty good about leaning towards big and heavy rather than small and fast. Let's try to determine if there's a real way to measure a cartridge's killing power - at least for comparison's sake.
Read about How Much Gun it Takes to Kill a Deer